On Thursday, Caesars Entertainment joined gaming rival MGM Resorts International in reporting that it was hit by a cyberattack, but added in a report to federal regulators that its casino and online operations were not disrupted.
The Reno-based publicly traded Caesars told the Securities and Exchange Commission that it could not guarantee that personal information about tens of millions of customers was secure following a data breach Sept. 7 that might have exposed driver's license and Social Security numbers of loyalty-rewards members.
"We have taken steps to ensure that the stolen data is deleted by the unauthorized actor," the company said, "although we cannot guarantee this result."
Brett Callow, a threat analyst for the New Zealand–based cybersecurity firm Emsisoft, said it was not clear if a ransom was paid or who was responsible for the intrusion at Caesars — or for the attack reported Monday by MGM Resorts.
Inside the Caesars breach
"Unofficially, we saw a group called Scattered Spider claimed responsibility," Callow said. "They appear to be native English speakers under the umbrella of a Russia-based operation called ALPHV or BlackCat."
Scattered Spider also is known as UNC3944, said Charles Carmakal, chief technical officer at cybersecurity firm Mandiant. He called the group "incredibly disruptive and aggressive" in recent targeting of hospitality and entertainment organizations.
"They leverage tradecraft that is challenging for many organizations with mature security programs to defend against," Carmakal said in a statement.
Mandiant said in a blog analysis published Thursday that the group uses SMS text phishing and phone calls to helpdesks to attempt to obtain password resets or multifactor bypass codes.
"This relatively new entrant in the ransomware industry has hit at least 100 organizations, most of them in the U.S. and Canada," Mandiant said.
Caesars is the largest casino owner in the world, with more than 65 million Caesars Rewards members and properties in 18 states and Canada under the Caesars, Harrah's, Horseshoe and Eldorado brands. It also has mobile and online operations and sports betting. Company officials did not respond to emailed questions from the Associated Press.
The company told the SEC that loyalty program customers were being offered credit monitoring and identity theft protection.
There was no evidence the intruder obtained member passwords, or bank account and payment-card information, the company reported, adding that operations at casinos and online "have not been impacted by this incident and continue without disruption."
More disruptive at MGM
The disclosure by Caesars came after MGM Resorts International, the largest casino company in Las Vegas, reported publicly on Monday that a cyberattack that it detected Sunday led it to shut down computer systems at its properties across the United States in order to protect data.
MGM Resorts said reservations and casino floors in Las Vegas and other states were affected. Customers shared stories on social media about not being able to make credit card transactions, obtain money from cash machines or enter hotel rooms. Some video slot machines were dark.
MGM Resorts has has about 40 million loyalty rewards members and tens of thousands of hotel rooms in Las Vegas at properties including the MGM Grand, Bellagio, Aria and Mandalay Bay. It also operates properties in China and Macau.
A company report on Tuesday to the SEC pointed to its Monday news release. The FBI said an investigation was ongoing but offered no additional information.
Some MGM Resorts computer systems were still down Thursday, including hotel reservations and payroll. But company spokesman Brian Ahern said its 75,000 employees in the U.S. and abroad were expected to be paid on time.
Callow of Emsisoft called most media accounts of the incidents speculative because information appeared to be coming from the same entities that claim to have carried out the attacks. He said recovery from cyberattacks can take months.
Callow pointed to reports that he called "plausible" that Caesars Entertainment was asked to pay $30 million for a promise to secure its data and might have paid $15 million. He also noted that the company did not describe in the SEC report the steps taken to ensure that the stolen data was secure.
The highest ransom believed to have been paid to cyberattackers was $40 million by insurance giant CNA Financial, Callow said, following a data breach in March 2021.
"In these cases, organizations basically pay to get a 'pinky promise,'" he said. "There is no way to actually know that [hackers] do delete [stolen data] or that it won't be used elsewhere."
Associated Press technology writer Frank Bajak in Boston contributed to this report.